West Catholic Athletics has a proud tradition of alumni who go on to play at the next level. The alumni listed below participated in DI or professional athletics.
- Anne Platte '70, Western Michigan University / St. Louis Streak, Basketball
- Mike Franckowiak '71, Central Michigan University / Denver Broncos & Buffalo Bills, Football
- Greg Meyer '73, University of Michigan / Boston Marathon Winner
- Kathy (Grzegorski) Johnson '81, Aquinas College / Grand Rapids Sports Hall of Fame, Basketball
- Scott Makarewicz '85, Michigan State University / Detroit Tigers & Houston Astros, Baseball
- Matt Jung '92, Loyola University - Chicago / Winlings (China), Basketball
- Sam Weatherhead '13, Michigan State University / Canadian Pro Golf Tour, Golf
- Kendra (Meyers) Hallagin '12, Central Michigan University, Track
- Libby (Schichtel) Garcia '12, University of Notre Dame, Track
- Joe Harmon '13, University of Detroit Mercy, Track
- Sam Weatherhead '13, Michigan State University, Golf
- Carl Myer '15, University of Michigan, Football & Track
- Mackenzie Ondersma '15, Central Michigan University, Golf
- Nick Solarewicz '15, University of Detroit Mercy, Tennis
- Mitch Stanitzek '15, Central Michigan University, Football
- Bryce Witham '15, University of Minnesota, Football
- Libby O'Brien '16, Central Michigan University, Track
- Zach Smith '16, Southeast Missouri University, Baseball
- Kyleen Hipp '00, Saint Francis University - Loretto, Basketball
- Tom Clifford '01, Eastern Michigan University, Cross Country & Track
- Anthony Grygorzyk '01, University of Michigan, Wrestling
- Joe Bockheim '04, Central Michigan University, Football
- Kyle Strotbaum '04, Michigan State University, Track
- Emily O'Hare '06, University of Dayton, Basketball
- Jake Sweedyk '06, Old Dominion University, Basketball
- Kyle Klein '08, Eastern Michigan University, Baseball
- Alex Wierenga '08, Oakland University, Baseball
- Antonio Schafer '09, Oakland University, Cross Country
- Olivia Sydow '09, Michigan State University, Cross Country & Track
- Kevin Czarnecki '90, U.S. Military Academy (Army), Football
- Chad Preston '90, Central Michigan University, Football
- Dustin Preston '90, Central Michigan University, Football
- Scott Simmons '90, Indiana University-Purdue University, Basketball & Tennis
- Brian Maksimowski '91, Central Michigan University, Wrestling
- Jennifer Merritt '91, Central Michigan University, Cross Country & Track
- Matt Jung '92, Loyola University - Chicago / Winlings (China), Basketball
- Mark Gole '94, Oakland University, Swimming
- Rachael Adams '95, Central Michigan University, Gymnastics
- Katie Clifford-Jazwinski '97, University of Michigan, Cross Country & Track
- Bernie Fuhs '99, University of Detroit Mercy, Basketball
- Jack Sczepaniuk '99, University of Detroit Mercy, Track
- Mike Cook '81, Central Michigan University, Football
- Chris Baar '82, Western Michigan University, Football
- Maggie Lillie-Smith '82, Western Michigan University, Cross Country & Track
- Mike Myszka '83, Miami Univerity (Ohio), Football
- Chris Pawloski '83, Western Michigan University, Basketball
- Carl Anderson '84, Indiana University, Cross Country
- Rosie Kehoe '84, University of Michigan, Swimming
- Amy Schaak '84, Michigan State University, Diving
- Scott Makarewicz '85, Michigan State University / Detroit Tigers & Houston Astros, Baseball
- Laura Schaak '85, Michigan State University, Diving
- Mary Torres '85, University of Michigan, Diving
- Tim Deregnacourt '86, University of Michigan, Track
- Anne Platte '70, Western Michigan University / St. Louis Streak, Basketball
- Mike Franckowiak '71, Central Michigan University / Denver Broncos & Buffalo Bills, Football
- Rick Jackson '72, Eastern Michigan University, Football
- Larry Munski '72, Eastern Michigan University, Track
- Greg Meyer '73, University of Michigan / Boston Marathon Winner, Cross Country & Track
- Al Zyskowski '73, Wake Forest University, Baseball & Football
- Larry Hohs '75, Michigan State University, Baseball
- Tami Poddell '77, Western Michigan University, Basketball
- Ed Meyle '79, Central Michigan University, Football
- Bob Mysliwiec '67, University of Notre Dame, Baseball
- Art Armijo '69, Western Michigan University, Football & Wrestling
- Ron Rasch '69, Western Michigan University, Football